Current:Home > StocksDefense attorneys for Boston Marathon bomber seek recusal of judge overseeing case-InfoLens
Defense attorneys for Boston Marathon bomber seek recusal of judge overseeing case
View Date:2025-01-12 00:58:14
BOSTON (AP) — Attorneys for Boston Marathon bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev are seeking to remove the judge overseeing the protracted legal battle over Tsarnaev’s death sentence.
Tsarnaev’s lawyers said during a hearing in federal court in Boston on Wednesday that U.S. District Court Judge George O’Toole should be recused from the case, pointing to what they said were comments O’Toole made about the case on podcasts and at public events during the appeals process.
Prosecutors said they are not opposed to a hearing on the issue, but they said they believe the motion is meritless.
O’Toole scheduled a hearing on the recusal request for next month. Tsarnaev was not in court.
“I want to dispose of that issue immediately, one way or another,” O’Toole said.
During the hearing, O’Toole also said all future filings connected to the case are to be done under seal to protect the integrity of the process.
A victim of the bombing, Mikey Borgard, attended Wednesday’s hearing.
Borgard said he was walking home from work on the day of the marathon when the bombs exploded. He suffered hearing loss and from post-traumatic stress disorder.
“I was 21 when the marathon happened. I’m 33 now. This has been a very, very long process and I really kind of wish it was over,” said Borgard, who wear hearing aides. Despite his injuries, Borgard said opposes capital punishment.
“I very strongly oppose the death penalty and that’s across the board. It does not matter who you are, I think the death penalty is inhumane,” he said. “That is essentially an eye for an eye, and that is very old way of looking at things.”
A federal appeals court in March ordered O’Toole to investigate the defense’s claims of juror bias and to determine whether Tsarnaev’s death sentence should stand following his conviction for his role in the bombing that killed three people and injured hundreds near the marathon’s finish line in 2013.
If O’Toole finds jurors should have been disqualified, he should vacate Tsarnaev’s sentence and hold a new penalty-phase trial to determine if Tsarnaev should be sentenced to death, the appeals court said.
In 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court reinstated the death sentence imposed on Tsarnaev after the 1st Circuit threw out the sentence in 2020. The circuit court found then that the trial judge did not sufficiently question jurors about their exposure to extensive news coverage of the bombing. The Supreme Court justices voted 6-3 in 2022 when they ruled that the 1st Circuit’s decision was wrong.
The 1st Circuit took another look at the case after Tsarnaev’s lawyers urged it to examine issues the Supreme Court didn’t consider. Among them was whether the trial judge wrongly forced the trial to be held in Boston and wrongly denied defense challenges to seating two jurors they say lied during questioning.
Tsarnaev’s guilt in the deaths of those killed in the bombing was not at issue in the appeal. Defense lawyers have argued that Tsarnaev had fallen under the influence of his older brother, Tamerlan, who died in a gun battle with police a few days after the April 15, 2013, bombing.
Tsarnaev was convicted of all 30 charges against him, including conspiracy and use of a weapon of mass destruction and the killing of Massachusetts Institute of Technology Police Officer Sean Collier during the Tsarnaev brothers’ getaway attempt.
veryGood! (38)
Related
- Chiefs block last-second field goal to save unbeaten record, beat Broncos
- Breaking at 2024 Paris Olympics: No, it's not called breakdancing. Here's how it works
- 'Stranger Things' prequel 'The First Shadow' is headed to Broadway
- BTS member Suga says sorry for drunk driving on e-scooter: 'I apologize to everyone'
- Wildfires burn from coast-to-coast; red flag warnings issued for Northeast
- Billy Bean was an LGBTQ advocate and one of baseball's great heroes
- Colin Farrell tears up discussing his son's Angelman syndrome: 'He's extraordinary'
- Severe flooding from glacier outburst damages over 100 homes in Alaska's capital
- Elena Rose has made hits for JLo, Becky G and more. Now she's stepping into the spotlight.
- Oklahoma parole board recommends governor spare the life of man on death row
Ranking
- Texas mother sentenced to 50 years for leaving kids in dire conditions as son’s body decomposed
- Michigan lawmaker who was arrested in June loses reelection bid in Republican primary
- Louisiana high court temporarily removes Judge Eboni Johnson Rose from Baton Rouge bench amid probe
- Watch stunning drone footage from the eye of Hurricane Debby
- As the transition unfolds, Trump eyes one of his favorite targets: US intelligence
- Connie Chiume, Black Panther Actress, Dead at 72: Lupita Nyong'o and More Pay Tribute
- US Open player compensation rises to a record $65 million, with singles champs getting $3.6 million
- Giants, Lions fined $200K for fights in training camp joint practices
Recommendation
-
Nevada Democrats keep legislative control but fall short of veto-proof supermajority
-
British swimmer Adam Peaty: There are worms in the food at Paris Olympic Village
-
Kansas City Chiefs CEO's Daughter Ava Hunt Hospitalized After Falling Down a Mountain
-
Boy who wandered away from his 5th birthday party found dead in canal, police say
-
Why Cynthia Erivo Needed Prosthetic Ears for Wicked
-
TikToker Nara Smith Addresses Hateful Criticism She and Husband Lucky Blue Smith Have Received
-
Olympic men's basketball bracket: Results of the 5x5 tournament
-
Vance jokes he’s checking out his future VP plane while overlapping with Harris at Wisconsin airport